Computational Physics (physics.comp-ph)

  • PDF
    We investigate the accuracy and robustness of one of the most common methods used in glaciology for the discretization of the $\mathfrak{p}$-Stokes equations: equal order finite elements with Galerkin Least-Squares (GLS) stabilization. Furthermore we compare the results to other stabilized methods. We find that the vertical velocity component is more sensitive to the choice of GLS stabilization parameter than horizontal velocity. Additionally, the accuracy of the vertical velocity component is especially important since errors in this component can cause ice surface instabilities and propagate into future ice volume predictions. If the element cell size is set to the minimum edge length and the stabilization parameter is allowed to vary non-linearly with viscosity, the GLS stabilization parameter found in literature is a good choice on simple domains. However, near ice margins the standard parameter choice may result in significant oscillations in the vertical component of the surface velocity. For these cases, other stabilization techniques, such as the interior penalty method, result in better accuracy and are less sensitive to the choice of the stabilization parameter. During this work we also discovered that the manufactured solutions often used to evaluate errors in glaciology are not reliable due to high artificial surface forces at singularities. We perform our numerical experiments in both FEniCS and Elmer/Ice.
  • PDF
    We formulate a general criterion for the exact preservation of the "lake at rest" solution in general mesh-based and meshless numerical schemes for the strong form of the shallow-water equations with bottom topography. The main idea is a careful mimetic design for the spatial derivative operators in the momentum flux equation that is paired with a compatible averaging rule for the water column height arising in the bottom topography source term. We prove consistency of the mimetic difference operators analytically and demonstrate the well-balanced property numerically using finite difference and RBF-FD schemes in the one- and two-dimensional cases.

Recent comments

Salvatore Mandrà Nov 21 2014 13:50 UTC

The manuscript has been widely revised to focus the reader's attention on the proposed method and its application in presence of local disorder.


Salvatore, Gian Giacomo and Alán

Salvatore Mandrà Aug 01 2014 19:11 UTC

Thanks Dr. Hastings for your comment. It is true that the transverse field Ising model does not satisfy the requirements to apply our method with an exponential reduction. Indeed, the opposite would be quite impressive since the random Ising model is a NP-Hard problem and we ourselves would be prett

Matt Hastings Aug 01 2014 16:43 UTC

The "quite general" conditions seem not to include the transverse field Ising model, the subject of most of the intensive numerical work previously. Incidentally, the terms "Lanczos" and "Krylov subspace" might be helpful.

Steve Flammia Jan 10 2014 08:01 UTC

This paper is an important first step towards making numerical and computational studies more easily checkable and reproducible. Very interesting stuff.

Noon van der Silk Jan 10 2014 16:26 UTC

Interestingly, another thematically-similar paper popped up today - (posting the link here as I assume not many people are subbed to cs.DL)