I've posted a public referee report on this paper here: https://nbviewer.jupyter.org/github/csferrie/openreviews/blob/master/arxiv.1703.10743/arxiv.1703.10743.ipynb
The manuscript has been widely revised to focus the reader's attention on the proposed method and its application in presence of local disorder.
Salvatore, Gian Giacomo and Alán
Thanks Dr. Hastings for your comment. It is true that the transverse field Ising model does not satisfy the requirements to apply our method with an exponential reduction. Indeed, the opposite would be quite impressive since the random Ising model is a NP-Hard problem and we ourselves would be prett
The "quite general" conditions seem not to include the transverse field Ising model, the subject of most of the intensive numerical work previously. Incidentally, the terms "Lanczos" and "Krylov subspace" might be helpful.
This paper is an important first step towards making numerical and computational studies more easily checkable and reproducible. Very interesting stuff.
Interestingly, another thematically-similar paper popped up today - https://scirate3.herokuapp.com/1401.2134 (posting the link here as I assume not many people are subbed to cs.DL)