General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology (gr-qc)

• Using complexity=action proposal we study the growth rate of holographic complexity for Lifshitz and hyperscaling violating geometries. We will consider both one and two sided black branes in an Einstein-Maxwell-Dilaton gravitational theory. We find that in either case Lloyd's bound is violated and the rate of growth of complexity saturates to a value which is greater than twice the mass of the corresponding black brane. This value reduces to the mass of the black brane in the isotropic case. We show that in two sided black brane the saturation happens from above while for one sided black brane it happens from below.
• We numerically investigate the gravitational waves generated by the head-on collision of equal-mass, self-gravitating, real scalar field solitons (oscillatons) as a function of their compactness $\mathcal{C}$. We show that there exist three different possible outcomes for such collisions: (1) an excited stable oscillaton for low $\mathcal{C}$, (2) a merger and formation of a black-hole for intermediate $\mathcal{C}$, and (3) a pre-merger collapse of both oscillatons into individual black-holes for large $\mathcal{C}$. For (1), the excited, aspherical oscillaton continues to emit gravitational waves. For (2), the total energy in gravitational waves emitted increases with compactness, and possesses a maximum which is greater than that from the merger of a pair of equivalent mass black-holes. The initial amplitudes of the quasi-normal modes in the post-merger ring-down in this case are larger than that of corresponding mass black-holes -- potentially a key observable to distinguish black-hole mergers with their scalar mimics. For (3), the gravitational wave output is indistinguishable from a similar mass, black-hole--black-hole merger.
• Feb 20 2018 gr-qc quant-ph arXiv:1802.06080v1
It is shown that a linearized classical gravity wave $\hat{a}$ \em la Einstein can get entangled with an array of test masses in a plane perpendicular to its direction of propagation. A Bell-CHSH inequality based on the requirement of noncontextuality for classical realism is derived, and it is shown that the entangled state produced violates this inequality.
• The homogeneous cosmological models with a Liouville scalar field are investigated in classical and quantum context of geometrodynamics. An integral of motion is used to eliminate the lapse function as the redundant degree of freedom, and analytical classical solutions in minisuperspace are obtained in a form suitable for further comparison with quantum dynamics. In the quantum case of quintessence field with potential unbounded from below and phantom field, the energy density operators are not essentially self-adjoint and self-adjoint extensions contain ambiguities. Therefore the same classical actions correspond to a family of distinct quantum models. Then the unitarity and appropriate classical limit can be achieved. For the phantom field the energy spectrum happens to be discrete. The appropriately localised wave packets are studied numerically using the Schrödinger's norm and a conserved Mostafazadeh's norm introduced from techniques of pseudo-Hermitian quantum mechanics. These norms give a similar packet evolution that is confronted with classical solutions.
• The idea of extra dimensions provides a promising approach to overcome various problems in modern physics. This includes theoretical as well as phenomenological aspects, such as the unification of the fundamental interactions or the hierarchy problem. Based on the seminal works by Kaluza and Klein that were published nearly 100 years ago, we denote theories with at least one compact periodic dimension as Kaluza-Klein theories. From a gravitational point of view the question arises, what are the fundamental solutions to Einstein's field equations of general relativity under these assumptions. In particular, in this work we are concerned with black hole solutions in Kaluza-Klein theory. Considering only the static case without electric charge, it turns out that there is a much richer phase space than in the usual four-dimensional theory, where only the Schwarzschild solution exists. There are at least two types of solutions with a completely different horizon topology: localized black holes with an ordinary spherical horizon and black strings with a horizon that wraps the compact dimension. Several arguments favor the conjecture that the solution branches of both types are connected via a singular topology changing solution that is controlled by the so-called double-cone metric. We study the regime close to this singular transit solution in five and six spacetime dimensions with the help of a highly accurate numerical scheme that we describe in detail. Consequently, for the first time we are able to show that in this regime the black objects exhibit a critical behavior, indicating that physical quantities are governed by universal critical exponents. Such exponents were already derived from the double-cone metric. We show that our data confirms these values extremely well. This provides compelling evidence in favor of the double-cone metric as the local model of the transit solution.
• Feb 20 2018 gr-qc arXiv:1802.06553v1
The suggestion of running gravitational coupling which tends to a non--Gaussian fixed point at high energies, keeps the theory safe from divergences at such a scale. We propose a way of improving the action using Kretschmann invariant as the cutoff identification parameter. The improved equations of motion and its spherically symmetric vacuum solution are obtained. Then the effects on the massive particles' trajectory and the black hole thermodynamics are studied.
• The notion of luminosity distance is most often defined in purely FLRW (Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker) cosmological spacetimes, or small perturbations thereof. However, the abstract notion of luminosity distance is actually much more robust than this, and can be defined non-perturbatively in almost arbitrary spacetimes. Some quite general results are already known, in terms of $dA_\mathrm{observer}/d\Omega_\mathrm{source}$, the cross-sectional area per unit solid angle of a null geodesic spray emitted from some source and subsequently detected by some observer. We shall reformulate these results in terms of a suitably normalized null geodesic affine parameter and the van Vleck determinant, $\Delta_{vV}$. The contribution due to the null geodesic affine parameter is effectively the inverse square law for luminosity, and the van Vleck determinant can be viewed as providing a measure of deviations from the inverse square law. This formulation is closely related to the so-called Jacobi determinant, but the van Vleck determinant has somewhat nicer analytic properties and wider and deeper theoretical base in the general relativity, quantum physics, and quantum field theory communities. In the current article we shall concentrate on non-perturbative results, leaving near-FLRW perturbative investigation for future work.
• We develop a model for frequency-domain gravitational waveforms from inspiraling binary neutron stars. Our waveform model is calibrated by comparison with hybrid waveforms constructed from our latest high-precision numerical-relativity waveforms and the SEOBNRv2T waveforms in the frequency range of $10$--$1000\,{\rm Hz}$. We show that the phase difference between our waveform model and the hybrid waveforms is always smaller than $0.1\, {\rm rad}$ for the binary tidal deformability, ${\tilde \Lambda}$, in the range $300\lesssim{\tilde \Lambda}\lesssim1900$ and for the mass ratio between 0.73 and 1. We show that, for $10$--$1000\,{\rm Hz}$, the distinguishability for the signal-to-noise ratio $\lesssim50$ and the mismatch between our waveform model and the hybrid waveforms are always smaller than 0.25 and $1.1\times10^{-5}$, respectively. The systematic error of our waveform model in the measurement of ${\tilde \Lambda}$ is always smaller than $20$ with respect to the hybrid waveforms for $300\lesssim{\tilde \Lambda}\lesssim1900$. The statistical error in the measurement of binary parameters is computed employing our waveform model, and we obtain results consistent with the previous studies. We show that the systematic error of our waveform model is always smaller than $20\%$ (typically smaller than $10\%$) of the statistical error for events with the signal-to-noise ratio of $50$.
• By using a bottom-up reconstruction technique for non-minimally coupled scalar-tensor theories, we realize the Einstein frame attractor cosmologies in the $\Omega (\phi)$-Jordan frame. For our approach, what is needed for the reconstruction method to work is the functional form of the non-minimal coupling $\Omega(\phi)$ and of the scalar-to-tensor ratio, and also the assumption of the slow-roll inflation in the $\Omega (\phi)$-Jordan frame. By appropriately choosing the scalar-to-tensor ratio, we demonstrate that the observational indices of the attractor cosmologies can be realized directly in the $\Omega (\phi)$-Jordan frame. We investigate the special conditions that are required to hold true in for this realization to occur, and we provide the analytic form of the potential in the $\Omega (\phi)$-Jordan frame. Also, by performing a conformal transformation, we find the corresponding Einstein frame canonical scalar-tensor theory, and we calculate in detail the corresponding observational indices. The result indicates that although the spectral index of the primordial curvature perturbations is the same in the Jordan and Einstein frames, at leading order in the $e$-foldings number, the scalar-to-tensor ratio differs. We discuss the possible reasons behind this discrepancy, and we argue that the difference is due to some approximation we performed to the functional form of the potential in the Einstein frame, in order to obtain analytical results, and also due to the difference in the definition of the $e$-foldings number in the two frames, which is also pointed out in the related literature. Finally, we find the $F(R)$ gravity corresponding to the Einstein frame canonical scalar-tensor theory.
• Colored triangulations offer a generalization of combinatorial maps to higher dimensions. Just like maps are gluings of polygons, colored triangulations are built as gluings of special, higher-dimensional building blocks, such as octahedra, which we call colored building blocks and known in the dual as bubbles. A colored building block is determined by its boundary triangulation, which in the case of polygons is simply characterized by its length. In three dimensions, colored building blocks are labeled by some 2D triangulations and those homeomorphic to the 3-ball are labeled by the subset of planar ones. Similarly to Euler's formula in 2D which provides an upper bound to the number of vertices at fixed number of polygons with given lengths, we look in three dimensions for an upper bound on the number of edges at fixed number of given colored building blocks. In this article we solve this problem when all colored building blocks, except possibly one, are homeomorphic to the 3-ball. To do this, we find a characterization of the way a colored building block homeomorphic to the ball has to be glued to other blocks of arbitrary topology in a colored triangulation which maximizes the number of edges. This local characterization can be extended to the whole triangulation as long as there is at most one colored building block which is not a 3-ball. The triangulations obtained this way are in bijection with trees. The number of edges is given as an independent sum over the building blocks of such a triangulation. In the case of all colored building blocks being homeomorphic to the 3-ball, we show that these triangulations are homeomorphic to the 3-sphere. Those results were only known for the octahedron and for melonic building blocks before. This article is self-contained and can be used as an introduction to colored triangulations and their bubbles from a purely combinatorial point of view.
• The article entitled $^"$Cosmic evolution in Brans-Dicke chameleon cosmology$^"$[Eur. Phys. J. Plus (2011) 126: 80], by Prof. Mubasher Jamil, et al., investigated cosmic evolution in an external interacting model of scaler tensor gravity namely Brans Dicke chameleon scenario. Although the procedure of this work contains novelties, but as it shall be realized from this comment their report faced three fatal drawbacks. In fact, one of them is related to the energy conservation equation, and the two remaining cases are about mathematical problems. In other words, in scalar tensor gravity models, to receive conservation equation a well known method is to combine Friedamnn equations with modified Klein-Gordon equation together. But in Prof. Jamil report, by virtue of this common method, one will not be able to find a true result for conservation equation. In addition, the mentioned mathematical problems lead to different results in comparison to their paper. In more clear words it will be shown, without introducing any new definitions or concepts, their report is wrong.
• We explore whether generalised Brans -- Dicke theories, which have a scalar field $\Phi$ and a function $\omega(\Phi)$, can be the effective actions leading to the effective equations of motion of the LQC and the LQC--inspired models, which have a massless scalar field $\sigma$ and a function $f(m) \;$. We find that this is possible for isotropic cosmology. We relate the pairs $(\sigma, f)$ and $(\Phi, \omega)$ and, using examples, illustrate these relations. We find that near the bounce of the LQC evolutions for which $f(m) = sin \; m$, the corresponding field $\Phi \to 0$ and the function $\omega(\Phi) \propto \Phi^2 \;$. We also find that the class of generalised Brans -- Dicke theories, which we had found earlier to lead to non singular isotropic evolutions, may be written as an LQC--inspired model. The relations found here in the isotropic cases do not apply to the anisotropic cases, which perhaps require more general effective actions.
• We consider the first order connection formulation of 4D general relativity in the radial gauge. We show how the partial gauge fixing of the phase space canonical coordinates leads to the appearance of second class constraints in the theory. We employ the gauge unfixing procedure in order to successfully complete the Dirac treatment of the system. While equivalent to the inversion of the Dirac matrix, the gauge unfixing allows us to work directly with the reduced phase space and the ordinary Poisson bracket. At the same time, we explicitly derive the new set of residual first class constraints preserving the partial gauge fixing, which are linear combinations of the original constraints, and these turn out to contain nonlinear terms. While providing an explicit example of how to consistently recast general relativity in a given partial gauge, the main motivation of this classical analysis is the application of the Quantum Reduced Loop Gravity program to a Schwarzschild black hole geometry.
• Feb 20 2018 gr-qc hep-th arXiv:1802.06135v1
We give a full analysis of the conservation along null surfaces of generalized energy and super-momenta, for gravitational systems enclosed by a finite boundary. In particular we interpret the conservation equations in a canonical manner, revealing a notion of symplectic potential and a boundary current intrinsic to null surfaces. This generalizes similar analyses done at asymptotic infinity or on horizons.
• We investigate the power-law, intermediate, and logamediate inflationary models in the framework of DBI non-canonical scalar field with constant sound speed. In the DBI setting, we first represent the power spectrum of both scalar density and tensor gravitational perturbations. Then, we derive different inflationary observables including the scalar spectral index $n_s$, the running of the scalar spectral index $dn_s/d\ln k$, and the tensor-to-scalar ratio $r$. We show that the 95\% CL constraint of the Planck 2015 T+E data on the non-Gaussianity parameter $f_{{\rm NL}}^{{\rm DBI}}$ leads to the sound speed bound $c_{s}\geq0.087$ in the DBI inflation. Moreover, our results imply that, although the predictions of the power-law, intermediate, and logamediate inflations in the standard canonical framework ($c_s=1$) are not consistent with the Planck 2015 data, in the DBI scenario with constant sound speed $c_s<1$, the result of the $r-n_s$ diagram for these models can lie inside the 68\% CL region favored by the Planck 2015 TT,TE,EE+lowP data. We also specify the parameter space of the power-law, intermediate, and logamediate inflations for which our models are compatible with the 68\% or 95\% CL regions of the Planck 2015 TT,TE,EE+lowP data. Using the allowed ranges of the parameter space of the intermediate and logamediate inflationary models, we estimate the running of the scalar spectral index and find that it is compatible with the 95\% CL constraint from the Planck 2015 TT,TE,EE+lowP data.

Mohammad Bavarian Sep 08 2016 03:58 UTC

So beautifully written!

Māris Ozols Sep 07 2016 13:03 UTC

John also has an excellent series of 7 blog posts covering this material:
https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/struggles-continuum-part-1/

Māris Ozols Feb 18 2016 14:29 UTC

"...structures seen in the universe today, from clusters of galaxies to Donald Trump."

Santiago Casas Apr 16 2015 14:05 UTC

Finally a good use for the Torsion tensor

Niel de Beaudrap Apr 03 2015 18:42 UTC

I put this on my reading list after the recent update, having a casual interest in foundations. While I don't have quite enough physics background to see if anything is being swept under the rug, I found it an interesting point of view, written clearly and without mysticism. In particular, I now un

...(continued)
Marco Piani Feb 15 2015 21:33 UTC

Well, this MUST be scited :-) I am surprised it was not already!

Mark M. Wilde Aug 01 2013 17:20 UTC

This paper was recently accepted into PRA. I was a referee for it and the comments in my final report were left as optional by the editors after it was discovered that I coauthored a paper on a similar topic. Since the final published version of the paper still contains some problems and the authors

...(continued)
Aram Harrow Jul 26 2012 16:32 UTC

They cite http://arxiv.org/abs/0908.3023 but I don't see how they address its criticism of the idea of making computational use of nonlinearity.

In particular, they respond to the paper by saying "In particular we
take the common view that if pure states are deterministically prepared and insert

...(continued)