Digital Libraries (cs.DL)

  • PDF
    It is widely recognized that citation counts for papers from different fields cannot be directly compared because different scientific fields adopt different citation practices. Citation counts are also strongly biased by paper age since older papers had more time to attract citations. Various procedures aim at suppressing these biases and give rise to new normalized indicators, such as the relative citation count. We use a large citation dataset from Microsoft Academic Graph and a new statistical framework based on the Mahalanobis distance to show that the rankings by well known indicators, including the relative citation count and Google's PageRank score, are significantly biased by paper field and age. We propose a general normalization procedure motivated by the $z$-score which produces much less biased rankings when applied to citation count and PageRank score.

Recent comments

lucy.vanderwende May 07 2015 16:13 UTC

The authors will want to look at work that Simone Teufel has done, in particular her Argumentative Zoning, which discusses the stance that the paper author takes with respect to the citations in that paper.

Steve Flammia Feb 05 2013 22:31 UTC

Here's our man: http://www.abdelaty.com/pup.htm
The links on the left are in Arabic, but some of them still have English text when you click through.

He also has an El Naschie-like photo montage of himself posing with famous scientists:
http://www.abdelaty.com/pic.htm

He is a prolific autho

...(continued)
Māris Ozols Feb 05 2013 15:57 UTC

This one is an interesting read...

It provides a novel way of measuring the impact factor and h-index as a percentage. In this way we can compare different journals and authors on an absolute scale! The only drawback is that the new method works only for Arabic journals.

Needless to say, the p

...(continued)
Earl Campbell Feb 06 2013 07:51 UTC

There is certainly some originality in the research of Abdel-Aty. For instance, he seems to be the first person to have gone realised that the concept of entanglement sudden death can be inverted to study entanglement sudden *birth*.

Earl Campbell Feb 06 2013 07:57 UTC

Also, seems that Barry Sanders has had some interaction with this Abdel-Aty before. According to:
http://elnaschiewatch.blogspot.de/2010/07/somethings-going-on-at-amis.html
Barry used to be managing editor of the AMIS journal, but is no involved in the journal!