Digital Libraries (cs.DL)

  • PDF
    Experimental data availability is a cornerstone for reproducibility in experimental fracture mechanics, which is crucial to the scientific method. This short communication focuses on the accessibility and long term availability of raw experimental data. The corresponding authors of the eleven most cited papers, related to experimental fracture mechanics, for every year from 2000 up to 2016, were kindly asked about the availability of the raw experimental data associated with each publication. For the 187 e-mails sent: 22.46% resulted in outdated contact information, 57.75% of the authors did received our request and did not reply, and 19.79 replied to our request. The availability of data is generally low with only $11$ available data sets (5.9%). The authors identified two main issues for the lacking availability of raw experimental data. First, the ability to retrieve data is strongly attached to the the possibility to contact the corresponding author. This study suggests that institutional e-mail addresses are insufficient means for obtaining experimental data sets. Second, lack of experimental data is also due that submission and publication does not require to make the raw experimental data available. The following solutions are proposed: (1) Requirement of unique identifiers, like ORCID or ResearcherID, to detach the author(s) from their institutional e-mail address, (2) Provide DOIs, like Zenodo or Dataverse, to make raw experimental data citable, and (3) grant providing organizations should ensure that experimental data by public funded projects is available to the public.

Recent comments

lucy.vanderwende May 07 2015 16:13 UTC

The authors will want to look at work that Simone Teufel has done, in particular her Argumentative Zoning, which discusses the stance that the paper author takes with respect to the citations in that paper.

Steve Flammia Feb 05 2013 22:31 UTC

Here's our man:
The links on the left are in Arabic, but some of them still have English text when you click through.

He also has an El Naschie-like photo montage of himself posing with famous scientists:

He is a prolific autho

Māris Ozols Feb 05 2013 15:57 UTC

This one is an interesting read...

It provides a novel way of measuring the impact factor and h-index as a percentage. In this way we can compare different journals and authors on an absolute scale! The only drawback is that the new method works only for Arabic journals.

Needless to say, the p

Earl Campbell Feb 06 2013 07:51 UTC

There is certainly some originality in the research of Abdel-Aty. For instance, he seems to be the first person to have gone realised that the concept of entanglement sudden death can be inverted to study entanglement sudden *birth*.

Earl Campbell Feb 06 2013 07:57 UTC

Also, seems that Barry Sanders has had some interaction with this Abdel-Aty before. According to:
Barry used to be managing editor of the AMIS journal, but is no involved in the journal!