Coherence makes quantum systems magical


Two primary facets of quantum technological advancement that hold great promise are quantum communication and quantum computation. For quantum communication, the canonical resource is entanglement. For quantum gate implementation, the resource is 'magic' in an auxiliary system. It has already been shown that quantum coherence is the fundamental resource for the creation of entanglement. We argue on the similar spirit that quantum coherence is the fundamental resource when it comes to the creation of magic. This unifies the two strands of modern development in quantum technology under the common underpinning of existence of quantum superposition, quantified by the coherence in quantum theory. We also attempt to obtain magic monotones inspired from coherence monotones and vice versa. We further study the interplay between quantum coherence and magic in a qutrit system and that between quantum entanglement and magic in a qutrit-qubit setting.
Submitted 15 Jan 2018 to Quantum Physics [quant-ph]
Published 16 Jan 2018
Updated 16 Jan 2018
Author comments: 13 pages, 4 figures, remarks/comments/suggestions welcome..... We thank F. Albarelli for pointing out an error in the previous version. Results remain unchanged


Blake Stacey Jan 17 2018 20:06 UTC (1 points)

Eq. (14) defines the sum negativity as $\sum_u |W_u| - 1$, but there should be an overall factor of $1/2$ (see arXiv:1307.7171, definition 10). For both the Strange states and the Norrell states, the sum negativity should be $1/3$: The Strange states (a.k.a., Hesse SIC vectors) have one negative entry in their Wigner representation, while the Norrell states each have two negative entries of value $-1/6$. This makes the greater robustness of the Strange states under incoherent noise easy to see, because mixing in the garbage state hits the Norrell states twice as hard.

Edited Jan 17 2018 20:13 UTC by Blake Stacey