Taming finite statistics for device-independent quantum information


The device-independent approach to physics is one where conclusions are drawn directly and solely from the observed correlations between measurement outcomes. In quantum information, this approach allows one to make strong statements about the properties of the underlying devices via the observation of Bell-inequality-violating correlations. However, since one can only perform a finite number of experimental trials, statistical fluctuations necessarily accompany any estimation of these correlations. Consequently, an important gap remains between the many theoretical tools developed for the asymptotic scenario and the experimentally obtained raw data. In particular, a sensible way to estimate the underlying quantum distribution has so far remained elusive. Here, we provide a set of tools to bridge this gap. Under the assumption that the experimental trials are independent and identically distributed, our methods allow one to achieve the analog of quantum state estimation in the device-independent setting by generating unique point estimates of the true quantum distribution. Our numerical results further suggest that these estimates converge toward the underlying distribution with a rate at least as good as the relative frequencies. As an application, we demonstrate how such estimates of the underlying quantum distribution can be used to provide sensible estimates of the amount of entanglement present in the measured system. In stark contrast with existing approach to device-independent parameter estimations, our estimation does not require the prior knowledge of any Bell inequality tailored for the specific property and the specific correlation of interest.
Submitted 25 May 2017 to Quantum Physics [quant-ph]
Published 26 May 2017
Updated 20 Jul 2017
Author comments: v2: 6 + 13 pages, 9 figures, text substantially revised to improved clarity, references updated